Todd Kohlhepp lived a double life that stunned many. On the surface, he was a regular real estate agent in South Carolina. But underneath this ordinary façade, Kohlhepp was hiding a dark and deadly secret. This article uncovers the shocking story of how Todd Kohlhepp went from selling homes to becoming one of the most infamous serial killers in the state.
Table of Contents
The Roots of a Troubled Mind: Todd Kohlhepp’s Early Years
Born in 1971 in the sunny city of Fort Lauderdale, Florida, Todd Christopher Kohlhepp’s life was marked by instability from the very beginning. Uprooted multiple times throughout his childhood due to his mother’s series of marriages and divorces, he lacked a stable home environment. His biological father’s absence loomed large, and his stepfather’s legal adoption did little to quell the underlying turmoil.
Even at a young age, Todd’s behavior raised red flags. Disturbing incidents, such as bleaching a goldfish and shooting at dogs with pellet guns, hinted at a deeper emotional disconnect. His destructive tendencies extended to his belongings, shredding clothes and showing little regard for material possessions. Concerned adults recognized the severity of his behavioral problems, and at the tender age of nine, Todd was referred to a behavioral institute in Georgia. The referral underscored his mother’s struggle to enforce limits and manage his increasingly troubling actions.
Three years later, in November 1986, Todd’s simmering anger boiled over. He targeted a 14-year-old neighborhood girl, fueled by rejection and a twisted desire for revenge. Luring her back to his house, he subjected her to a horrific ordeal, using duct tape, threats, and sexual violence. Though he eventually walked her home, his menacing threats left her terrified and convinced of his capability for further harm.
Despite her fear, the brave young girl spoke up, confiding in her family about the trauma she endured. Swift action followed, and within 90 minutes of the abduction, Todd was arrested at home. The consequences were severe; he spent the next 15 years in an Arizona prison. During sentencing, a probation officer issued a chilling warning about Todd’s lack of remorse, suggesting that his absence of a conscience could lead to future crimes.
Deflecting responsibility, Todd blamed his father’s absence and frequent dalliances with women for his own actions. Meanwhile, he desperately pleaded with his mother to allow him to return to her, a plea she evaded with a series of excuses.
This incident marked a turning point in Todd’s life, solidifying his trajectory toward a life of violence and manipulation. The seeds of his future crimes were sown, and the echoes of his past traumas continued to haunt him, shaping the monster he would eventually become.
Scarred by Rejection: The Transformation of Todd Kohlhepp.
The sting of rejection haunted Todd from his earliest years, leaving a profound mark on his psyche. He internalized the perceived lack of love from multiple women in his life, including his own mother, fixating on the idea that their affections were directed elsewhere. This deep-seated wound festered, potentially serving as the catalyst for his eventual descent into darkness. Rejection became a recurring theme, fueling his rage and driving him to inflict devastating consequences on those who dared to spurn him.
But despite his troubled past and violent tendencies, Todd embarked on a surprising path while incarcerated for 15 years as a teenager. In the confines of an adult prison, he adopted the guise of a model inmate, meticulously adhering to the rules and exhibiting minimal disruptive behavior. During his sentence and upon release, he diligently worked towards securing a job and even pursued higher education.
Through sheer determination, Todd seemingly reinvented himself, shedding his troubled past and embracing a new, outwardly reformed persona. This dramatic transformation, however, masked the darkness that still lurked beneath the surface, waiting for the right moment to resurface.
The Superbike Motorsports Massacre: Todd Kohlepp Resurfacing of Violence
Upon his release from prison, Todd returned to Spartanburg, determined to forge a new life. He secured a job as a graphic designer, further solidifying his outward transformation into a seemingly reformed individual. However, in 2003, his simmering rage resurfaced when he purchased a GSX-R750 motorcycle from Superbike Motorsports, a popular local dealership.
He returned to the motor shop, hoping to discuss returning the bike due to his lack of riding experience. However, he left feeling humiliated and disrespected, claiming the employees had laughed and mocked him. Days later, the bike was stolen, and Todd fixated on the suspicion that the employees at Superbike were responsible. The familiar sting of humiliation and ridicule ignited his anger, triggering the same feelings of rejection that had haunted him throughout his life.
Consumed by resentment, Todd plotted his revenge. On November 6, 2003, he armed himself with a Beretta 92FS and three 10-round magazines. Abruptly leaving his Greenville Technical College class, he drove to Boiling Springs, stopping at a CVS parking lot to don his shoulder holster.
With chilling premeditation, he entered Superbike Motorsports, patiently waiting for the last customer to depart before unleashing his deadly intentions. As soon as the coast was clear, Todd ruthlessly executed Scott Ponder (the owner), Brian Lucas (the shop manager), Beverly Guy (Scott’s mother and bookkeeper), and Chris Sherbert (a mechanic).
In the wake of his calculated massacre, Todd vanished into the night, leaving behind a scene of unimaginable horror. A loyal customer, arriving shortly after the murders, stumbled upon the lifeless bodies of Scott and Brian in the parking lot. The customer immediately alerted authorities, who arrived swiftly to confront the largest crime scene Spartanburg had ever witnessed. The gruesome discovery prompted a frantic search of the building, where the remaining victims were found.
Despite the magnitude of the tragedy, investigators found themselves with few leads. Todd had meticulously covered his tracks, leaving behind minimal physical evidence. The case quickly turned cold, and the grieving families were left without answers or justice.
Todd Kohlepp’s Double Life Unveiled: The Real Estate Agent with a Dark Past
Following the Superbike Motorsports massacre, Todd seamlessly resumed his studies, leading a double life in a small city in upstate South Carolina. He maintained his outward appearance of normalcy, successfully concealing his violent tendencies. In June 2006, Todd made a bold move to further legitimize his new identity.
He wrote a heartfelt letter to the South Carolina Real Estate Commission, requesting permission to take the state real estate exam. In this letter, he downplayed his past crimes, describing the sexual assault of the teenager as a “grave misunderstanding” that led to his 15-year incarceration. He conveniently omitted any mention of the duct tape, sexual assault, or threats he had made against his victim’s family. Remarkably, three weeks after sending this deceitful letter, Todd became an official real estate agent.
He threw himself into his newfound profession, establishing his own company, TKA Real Estate. He quickly rose to prominence, becoming the lead broker with nearly a dozen agents working under him. Outwardly, he appeared to be a successful businessman, owning multiple BMWs, motorcycles, and other possessions that highlighted his wealth. However, his true nature remained hidden. Many who knew him described him as arrogant, boastful, and obsessed with firearms, leaving an unsettling impression on those around him.
In 2007, Todd purchased a home in Moore, a town southwest of Spartanburg, and a 100-acre property in Woodruff. This picturesque land, with its rolling hills and lush trees, was immediately transformed into a fortress when Todd enclosed the property with an imposing $80,000 high chain-link fence, effectively isolating it from the outside world. Neighbors grew increasingly suspicious as they heard the constant echo of gunfire emanating from the property at night, wondering what sinister activities were taking place behind the barriers. Their unease grew, confirming their suspicions that Todd was not who he seemed.
A Fatal Attraction: Todd Kohlhepp’s Pursuit of Unconditional Acceptance
Driven by a deep-seated fear of rejection, Todd yearned for a woman who would never abandon or betray him. His quest for unconditional acceptance led him down a dark path, ultimately culminating in tragedy.
In the festive season of Christmas 2015, a young married couple, Johnny Joe Coxie (29) and Meagan Leigh McCraw-Coxie (26), vanished without a trace in Spartanburg.
The couple had been employed by Todd to work on his secluded Woodruff property. Initially, there was no reason to suspect his involvement in their disappearance. Law enforcement focused their efforts elsewhere, unaware that the real estate agent with a seemingly ordinary life was harboring a sinister secret.
The couple’s disappearance marked another chapter in his twisted saga, fueled by his desperate desire for control and his twisted perception of love. The idyllic landscape of his Woodruff property became a hunting ground for his dark fantasies, where rejection would be met with the ultimate punishment.
A Descent into Darkness: The Disappearance of Kala Brown and Charlie Carver
Months after the mysterious vanishing of the Coxie couple in 2015, another couple, Kala Brown and Charlie Carver, became ensnared in Todd’s web of deceit. The couple’s paths crossed through Kala’s mother, who had introduced them, and they had remained friends for years before their relationship blossomed into romance in August 2016. Unbeknownst to them, this new chapter in their lives would lead to a harrowing ordeal.
Kala, who occasionally cleaned houses for Todd, mentioned her new boyfriend Charlie to her employer. Needing help with some outdoor work on his Woodruff property, Todd offered the couple a job clearing land and creating pathways. They accepted, unaware of the sinister intentions lurking beneath Todd’s seemingly ordinary facade.
On August 31st, Charlie failed to show up for his scheduled overtime shift at his regular job. His mother, alarmed by his sudden silence, frantically texted and called him, but received no response. A visit to his apartment yielded no clues, and days turned into agonizing weeks with no word from her son. The family’s growing concern prompted them to file a missing person report with the police.
As the search for Charlie intensified, his family took to social media, posting flyers and reaching out to the media for help. The story of the missing couple gained public attention, but the mystery deepened when peculiar posts began appearing on Kala Brown and Charlie Carver’s social media accounts. The posts claimed they were safe and had gotten married, but their families knew something was terribly wrong. The language used in the posts was uncharacteristic of Charlie, riddled with grammatical errors and misspellings, raising alarm bells for his loved ones.
Law enforcement investigated the online activity, tracking Facebook messages, credit card information, and awaiting cell phone pings. The agonizing wait stretched into weeks, then months, with no sign of Charlie. His family’s initial fears of an accident morphed into a chilling realization that something far more sinister had occurred. The 65-day ordeal became an unbearable test of endurance as the family grappled with the agonizing uncertainty of the couple’s fate.
A Glimmer of Hope: The Discovery of Kala Brown
On November 3, 2016, a crucial breakthrough occurred in the investigation into the disappearance of Kala Brown and Charlie Carver. Kala’s cell phone had pinged off several towers in the area northwest of Woodruff, an area dominated by Todd’s sprawling property. This vital information led law enforcement to focus their efforts on two locations: Todd’s Woodruff property and his residence in Moore, South Carolina, located 20 minutes apart.
At the Woodruff property, a team of investigators meticulously combed through the woods, eventually stumbling upon a renovated barn. While the barn was empty, a chilling discovery awaited them nearby: a shipping container fortified with multiple padlocks, chains, and bolts. The ominous sight raised immediate suspicions, prompting the investigators to take immediate action.
After sixty-five agonizing days, signs of life emerged from within the container, exceeding the investigators’ bleakest expectations. They wasted no time in attempting to open the container, utilizing drills and bolt cutters to gain access. Finally, they breached the metal enclosure and found Kala inside, her arms raised above her head and handcuffed to the wall. She lay on her back, her neck and one leg chained to the wall like a captive animal, severely restricting her movements.
Paramedics and officers rushed to her aid, carefully freeing her from the shackles that had held her captive. As she was liberated from her prison, Kala recounted the harrowing details of her ordeal, shedding light on the depraved depths of Todd’s crimes. He had made Kala his sex slave, raping her repeatedly multiple times a day. When asked about Charlie, Kala replied:
Todd Kohlhepp shot Charlie Carver three times in the chest, wrapped him in a blue tarp, put him in the bucket of the tractor, locked me down here, and I never seen him again. He says he’s dead and buried.
As she recounted her harrowing experience, a chilling revelation emerged: she and Charlie were not Todd’s first victims. The missing married couple, Johnny and Meagan, had also met a tragic end at his hands. Lured to the property with the promise of employment, the couple’s modest lifestyle and history of petty crimes made them vulnerable targets for his predatory nature. Upon their arrival, Todd turned on them, unleashing his violent tendencies. Meagan, held captive for a week, fought desperately for her freedom, but her valiant struggle ultimately led to her demise.
Kala was forced to endure Todd’s twisted confessions, learning that the body count extended far beyond the Coxies. He boasted of a murder count nearing triple digits, claiming to have seized opportunities to kill during his travels around the world. He even hinted at the gruesome reality of multiple bodies buried throughout his property.
The race against time to locate Charlie and uncover the extent of Todd’s crimes intensified as the horrifying truth of his double life as a real estate agent and serial killer began to unravel.
The Walls Close In: Todd Kohlhepp’s Deceptive Front Crumbles
As officers apprehended Todd at his Moore residence, unaware of the simultaneous discovery unfolding on his Woodruff property, they delivered a bombshell that shattered his carefully constructed front. With a calm demeanor, an officer informed him that Kala had been found alive on his property, locked inside a storage container.
All right, this is where we’re at, Mr. Kohlhepp. While we were here, all right, my sergeant served a search warrant on your property, ok… We have Kala.
Todd’s initial reaction was one of feigned disbelief. “Excuse me?” he retorted, attempting to maintain his composure. The officer patiently reiterated the information, emphasizing that Kala had been rescued from his property and had not left since her disappearance. As the gravity of the situation dawned upon him, Todd’s expression shifted, a mix of confusion and apprehension clouding his face.
The officer continued to explain the grim details, revealing that Kala had been held captive for an extended period, chained and confined within the metal container. The news seemed to shake Todd’s carefully constructed image of a respectable real estate agent. Officers added:
If you wanna help yourself, tell us where Charlie’s at so we can go find his body.
Faced with the mounting evidence against him, Todd remained defiant. He refused to assist in locating Charlie and vehemently denied any involvement in his disappearance. He maintained his innocence, claiming he had not locked Kala in the container and asserting his right to legal counsel.
Frustrated by his lack of cooperation, law enforcement had no choice but to arrest him on charges of kidnapping. Todd’s refusal to provide any information hindered the investigation and left the fate of Charlie uncertain. As the case progressed, investigators would have to rely on the evidence they had gathered and the chilling revelations from Kala to unravel the full extent of Todd’s crimes.
The Horrifying Confessions: A Serial Killer’s Warped Pride
Just a day after Kala’s rescue, investigators uncovered the grim truth about Charlie’s fate. His lifeless body was discovered on the Woodruff property—his identity confirmed by his distinctive tattoos. With Kala’s harrowing account and the physical evidence, detectives pieced together the tragic events that unfolded upon the couple’s arrival at the property.
Upon reaching the garage, Todd had immediately opened fire on Charlie, mercilessly shooting him three times in the chest. His motive became chillingly clear: he desired Kala and saw Charlie as an obstacle to be eliminated. Todd believed that by killing someone a person loved, he could exert ultimate control over them, a twisted logic he applied to his manipulation of Kala.
Following his arrest, clad in an orange prison jumpsuit, he sat before interrogators, his arrogance on full display as he recounted the details of his heinous crimes. With chilling detachment, he described the murders of Meagan and Johnny Coxie, the first known couple to fall victim to his depravity. His confession shed light on the depths of his psychopathy, revealing a cold-blooded killer who took pleasure in inflicting pain and suffering:
She panicked and I told her to sit down, and she sat down. I handcuffed her, patted her down, tied her up, and left her there while I figure out what to do. Got rid of Johnny, came back, left her there, went and got food, fed the girl. I held her there for a couple of days. I walked her outside and put a bullet right in the back of her head.
In a devastating discovery, the bodies of the young couple were ultimately found buried on Todd’s Woodruff property, further solidifying the extent of his depravity. However, the horrors were far from over. Just days later, Todd made a shocking confession, admitting to being the sole perpetrator behind the unsolved quadruple homicide at Superbike Motorsports. He revealed intricate details about the murders of Scott Ponder, Brian Lucas, Beverly Guy, and Chris Sherbert, information only the killer could possess.
His arrogance and lack of remorse were evident in his chilling accounts of the shootings. He described each murder with disturbing detail, emphasizing that all victims were shot in the head. He spoke of the killings as if they were a sport, a game in which he excelled. His twisted pride in his actions sent shockwaves through the community and law enforcement alike:
I bought a motorcycle from them. I had gone back to them and told them that I was having a hard time riding it and I was not so sure that I’d made a wise decision because I was inexperienced. They preceded to give me…on the rude side… about my inability to ride that kind of bike.
As the interrogation continued, Todd delved into the chilling details of his crimes, revealing the calculated and methodical approach he employed in hunting his victims. He spoke with a disturbing detachment, describing how he stalked his prey, patiently waiting for the opportune moment to strike. His words painted a picture of a predator meticulously planning each attack, carefully selecting his targets and executing his plans with chilling precision.
The Superbike Motorsports massacre, he explained, was no different. He had meticulously observed the shop’s routine, identifying the employees who would be present after closing hours. He had chosen his weapon carefully, ensuring its lethal efficiency. And when the time came, he entered the shop with cold determination, carrying out his gruesome plan without hesitation. Todd said:
I sat on a few bikes, did my usual, basically stalling for time and doing my best to make sure the paying customers were not there. Collateral damage is not cool… I preceded to go to the back where the mechanic was prepping the bike. Walked up, pulled out the Baretta, pulled the safety off. I shot the mechanic twice, downward angle. Twice, maybe a third time, I didn’t really count.
From the one side, I don’t want to waste rounds… the other side you definitely need the desired effect. Once I realized he was no longer a threat, I immediately proceeded towards the front of the building. At that time all three—manager, owner, and mom—heard the gunshots in the back and was coming to see what happened.
Mom was closest and I shot her two or three times in the chest… I was not gunning for the mom, but she was there at the time, she was working there but she got thrown into it, she wasn’t the primary target. She fell, the owner and the manager ran for the door. Took off.
At that range, they should have run to me and not away. They were way too close. In the process of that, I popped a few rounds and got one in the back. He [Brian Lucas] crumpled in the door. I put two or three rounds in him [Scott Ponder], did a reload, and he was still running. I put 2 rounds in him, and he fell outside.
I will tell you once I engaged, I was engaged. At that point it was almost like a video game… I cleared that building in under 30 seconds. You guys would have been proud. I’m sorry, but you guys would’ve been proud.
Todd’s chilling confession offered a glimpse into the mind of a serial killer, revealing the twisted logic and meticulous planning that fueled his reign of terror. His words sent a shiver down the spines of investigators, confirming their worst fears about the depths of his depravity.
Additional “Serial Killers” Crime Stories
- 5 Ohio Serial Killers: Deadliest Murderers from Ohio
- Ted Bundy: The Charismatic Serial Killer Who Terrorized America
- Which State in the USA Has Most Serial Killers?
Plea Bargain Spares Todd Kohlhepp from Death Row
Finally, in May 2017, after months of negotiations, Todd entered a plea deal. In exchange for avoiding the death penalty and a lengthy trial, he agreed to seven consecutive life sentences without parole. The families of the victims, while yearning for harsher punishment, reluctantly accepted the deal, hoping to finally find closure and avoid the prolonged agony of a drawn-out legal battle.
Todd’s admission of guilt and incarceration provided closure to the Superbike Motorsports massacre, bringing justice for the murders of Charlie Carver, and Meagan and Johnny Coxie. Kala Brown, though forever scarred by the events of that tragic night, received the justice she deserved, ultimately awarded $6,318,760 in a lawsuit against Todd. 7 News reports:
She wanted $360 million in punitive damages and $3.6 million in actual and compensatory damages for past and future medical costs, pain and suffering, mental anguish and loss of enjoyment of life, according to Bannister, Wyatt & Stalvey, LLC.
The Monster Among Us: The Cautionary Tale of Todd Kohlhepp
The disturbing saga of Todd Kohlhepp serves as a chilling cautionary tale, underscoring the deceptive nature of evil. His ability to seamlessly blend into society as a respected real estate agent while harboring a sinister secret highlights the importance of remaining vigilant and trusting our instincts. Todd’s story reminds us that appearances can be deceiving, and that even the most seemingly ordinary individuals can harbor dark and dangerous desires.
His case serves as a stark reminder of the importance of thorough background checks and the need for continued vigilance in our communities. Moreover, his manipulative tendencies and exploitation of vulnerable individuals underscore the importance of fostering healthy relationships and support systems to protect ourselves and our loved ones from those who seek to harm us.
Todd Kohlhepp Documentary
The most notable documentary about Todd Kohlhepp is the 2019 series Serial Killer: Devil Unchained. This three-part series delves into the chilling case of Todd Kohlhepp, a seemingly successful real estate agent in South Carolina who harbored a dark secret: he was a prolific serial killer. It follows investigative journalist Maria Awes as she receives a call from Kohlhepp himself, claiming to have committed more murders than the seven he was already convicted of.
The documentary features interviews with former FBI profiler John Douglas and Todd’s biographer, offering insight into his disturbing psychology and motivations. Awes works tirelessly to uncover the truth behind Todd’s claims, visiting crime scenes, interviewing witnesses, and piecing together the puzzle of his hidden life. The series also explores the devastating impact of Todd’s crimes on the victims’ families and the community at large.
Other Documentaries and TV Episodes Featuring Todd Kohlhepp:
- “Inside the Mind of a Serial Killer” (2016) – This episode focuses on Todd’s case, analyzing his behavior and the factors that contributed to his crimes.
- “Making a Serial Killer” (Season 1, Episode 3) – This episode examines Todd’s life and the events leading up to his capture.
These documentaries offer a chilling look into the mind of a serial killer and the devastating consequences of his actions. They are a must-watch for anyone interested in true crime and the psychology of those who commit such heinous acts.
Watch “Serial Killer: Devil Unchained”
Maria Awes, an investigative journalist, embarks on a quest to uncover the full scope of serial killer Todd Kohlhepp’s horrific deeds, including both his confirmed crimes and the additional murders he alleges to have carried out.
FAQs
Is Todd Kohlhepp still Alive?
Yes, Todd Kohlhepp is still alive. He is serving seven consecutive life sentences without the possibility of parole at the Broad River Correctional Institution in Columbia, South Carolina. Kohlhepp was convicted of multiple murders and other crimes, including the infamous “Superbike Motorsports” murders and the kidnapping and imprisonment of Kala Brown.
Who was the superbike killer?
The “Superbike Killer” is a nickname given to Todd Kohlhepp, an American serial killer and former real estate agent. On November 6, 2003, Kohlhepp entered the Superbike Motorsports motorcycle shop in Chesnee, South Carolina, and shot and killed four people: Scott Ponder, the shop’s owner; Beverly Guy, Ponder’s mother; Brian Lucas, the service manager; and Chris Sherbert, the mechanic.
What psychological traits are associated with Todd Kohlhepp?
Kohlhepp has been described as having traits consistent with psychopathy, including a lack of empathy, manipulative behavior, and a desire for control.
